Go On, Have a Happy New Year’s War
Every new year’s first blog post should be bright and chirpy but that’s not for me. I write war novels. So how about a biting lesson on an always popular sport – war – and how to survive it?
There are two great lessons a soldier must learn in order to put him- or herself in the right frame of mind to do what must done in combat and, incidentally, survive war. I'll tell you about the first lesson now and the second some other time, if you insist.
Lesson One: Yes, yes, you really really really want to learn to be the best soldier you can be. Not because being best is any guarantee that you'll live to stagger out the ass-end of your war. But because it means you'll have some slight chance to kill enough of the enemy to justify – at least to you – your own risk of death in combat.
Because the best soldier with the best training and the best weapons and the very best bloody-minded combat attitude has no more chance of survival than that confused Sad Sack over there deep down in the next foxhole too frightened to poke up his/her head to fire a weapon.
How can that be when the best is best, isn't it? Oh, maybe in a competitive sport like basketball or love. Not in combat. Combat isn't a sport and not a competition. Not at the level of the grunt in the mud. It isn't even movie gladiators in the Colosseum, with or without added raging lions.
No, combat is about filling the air around a soldier with little bits of steel. Like bullets and shrapnel. All designed not merely to kill but to so mangle and maim any it does not kill so as to force the enemy nation to waste resources meant for winning its war on caring for the war-wounded, instead.
Imagine yourself standing up-up-up in all that air filled with little bits of steel flying around you at supersonic speeds. Because that is what a soldier (or sailor or Marine or airman) is expected to do. At that moment, which would you rather have handy to keep yourself alive – the very best training-weapon-combat attitude or just a tiny bit of good luck?
Luck, ladies and gents, boys and girls, is what separates the quick from the dead in combat. Thus endeth Lesson One.
Oh, not quite. Because I can hear your puzzled whimpers and the fierce grumbles of the old soldiers who train new soldiers.
Question: Why do armies grow weaker as their wars grow longer? Because they've used up all their best soldiers, those so trained and self-driven as to laugh at luck and take the lead charging into the enemy's killing machine.
Consider the Russians in Ukraine, for example, who now shove convicts and their allies' soldiers into their front lines ahead of Russian troops. A curious thing to ponder, isn't it?
But don't soldiers learn anything in combat to help them survive? Of course they do. There were GIs who fought all across Europe after Normandy and came home to tell about it. Combat trained them to be the greatest soldiers this country ever produced. But how many other soldiers original to their companies sailed home with them? Very few. Those greatest soldiers were also the luckiest.
Consider the famous Omaha Beach invasion scene from the film Saving Private Ryan. How many best soldiers died on that beach beside all the average and mediocre before any of them fired a single bullet? Luck decided.
Or consider wounded Audie Murphy standing on a burning tank destroyer firing its .50 machine gun and calling in artillery support to hold off German tanks and soldiers as his outnumbered company fell back to better fighting positions. A superb soldier and great hero but luck offered him no help? (Btw, his To Hell and Back is one fine war memoir.)
I think of seeing a soldier, going-home orders in his pocket, clinging to the strut of a chopper lifting him and the wounded out of jungle combat when the chopper jinked and he fell into the trees and broke his back. Of a mech infantry trooper who, napping after an exhausting patrol, had his head crushed beneath the track of his own armored personnel carrier. Or of the old NCO on his second combat tour running through bullet-heavy air, blood streaming from a zip! across his shaved scalp, shouting, “I’m going home I’m going home!”
Luck decides all in combat for the individual soldier.
So how can a soldier get a fair share of combat luck? You can't. It happens to you or it doesn't. Like love or a lightning strike. Which leaves us with two last things to say about luck:
As combat luck is uncertain, choose your war. If it’s December 7, 1941, go fight and take your chances. There’s nothing else you can do. But if it’s some other date, give the thing real thought before you sign up to tease your luck.
Then recall that the novelist James Jones fought on Guadalcanal where the combat was so murderously awful that he and his buddies preemptively gave themselves up for dead. Giving up, he said, relieved fear and helped them survive, and win the grueling battle. If luck is so damn fickle, then you might as well follow his example and go to war considering yourself dead – after all, you being dead is what any war you join is all about. But that attitude just might maybe bring you the slim luck that let James Jones survive to write The Thin Red Line.
If all this sounds too grim for a jolly New Year’s post, then tell me – what do you think war is?
© 2025 Steven Hardesty